Venetian island residents howl at Miami Beach when cars get towed from their neighborhood

On Saturday, the tow trucks rolled to Rivo Alto and DiLido islands on the Venetian Causeway, at the orders of the city of Miami Beach.

They towed more than a dozen cars.

Some belonged to island homeowners. Some belonged to their friends. Some belonged to workers with jobs at one of the homes.

Here’s an account from Rivo Alto resident Tony Santos:

“A complaint was sent in by someone on Rivo Alto that there were cars parked on the pavement in front of homes.  Based on that complaint, MB Parking Enforcement came out and ticketed and towed cars parked on the city streets on Rivo Alto.

“I stopped them from towing my wife’s car this morning because I heard a terribly loud noise of a truck in front of my home for a little while; otherwise there was no warning of any kind at any time.  The MB Parking Enforcement officer confirmed that to me as well.  While she was very professional (and I have to admit that given the fact I rousted out of bed, I was not taking too kindly to the situation), she stood by her orders.  Upon promising to move the vehicle, I placed it in neighbor’s driveway.”

By the count of some residents, the city had at least seven cars towed from the front of homes on DiLido Island, in addition to cars ticketed and towed from Rivo Alto.

The action created a furor on the islands during the weekend, and demands that Miami Beach city hall back off.

The issue, according to Venetian Island Homeowner Association president Greg Carney, is the city classifies the tiny streets on the three city Venetian islands — Rivo Alto, DiLido and San Marino — to be highways. And ordinances say “that vehicles cannot be parked in the travel lanes of HIGHWAYS,” Carney said in a letter to homeowners.

“The idea is twofold as I understand the Parking Department’s or CIty Attorney Office’s interpretation,” Carney wrote. “First, you don’t want cars being parked to create a hazard.  The idea here is if cars are parked in travel lanes on major through streets like Alton Road or the Venetian Causeway, fast moving traffic will be forced into the path of oncoming fast moving traffic, which creates an obvious safety issue.
“Second, vehicles should not be parked in such a way as to force pedestrians out into fast moving traffic for obvious safety reasons.
“In addition, there is another requirement that there be enough of a travel lane maintained on any public street whether HIGHWAY or not that emergency vehicles (e.g., police cars, fire trucks, ambulances, etc) be able to get by without hinderance for obvious reasons.”
Of course, the roads on the Venetian Islands do not function as thoroughfares like Alton Road or the Venetian Causeway.
One resident, who has lived on the island for 18 years, posted this note on a message board:
I got a ticket 4 months ago for parking in front of my house but not in my driveway.  I had no room because maids, maintenance, pool guy, etc. were there.  This is a problem and should be addressed.  We should be able to park near our homes…. there is no where to go.  There needs to be a way to handle all of this!
Carney said the city ought to apply some logic to its enforcement.
“The only rational solution, as I  have discussed with the City on a number of occasions, is to have the City interpret that the ordinance does not apply to non-HIGHWAYS and to deem our streets not to be HIGHWAYS,” Carney said.
“I strongly urge them to get this resolved once and for all: it seems as if it should be easy – modify the official interpretation of the ordinance and tell Parking to leave the residents alone.  I think it highly unlikely that the county or the State will come after the city for how it enforces parking on local city streets even if the county or state thinks our streets are HIGHWAYS.  Cut the residents some slack.”
He called on island residents to contact the city manager and their commissioners “to express frustration over this issue.  It sure has frustrated me.”

6 responses to “Venetian island residents howl at Miami Beach when cars get towed from their neighborhood

  1. On the other hand, there are often cars–mostly very large trucks–parked in the service roads that go north along Collins Avenue to serve to allow residents of the condominium buildings to enter and exit their buildings. Along where I am at 52th and Collins, If I am trying to return home by way of Collins (only way to do that) I must dodge large trucks just parked there for long periods of time, often obscuring the entrance to our building’s driveway.

    Annoying, unsafe, ignored entirely by Miami Beach parking or traffic authorities. What is large firetruck had to arrive here? This has been often brought to their attention.

    How come they are so intense on the V. Islands? Why not here? Can it be because of the favored hotels in this neighborhood?

  2. Towing and discos are two of the largest industries in Miami Beach. They get pandering at the expense of residents. Always have and apparently always will. City Hall just doesn’t get it. Never have, never will. Moved off of Rivo Alto 12 years ago. No regrets.

  3. There is also the issue (so I’ve heard from sources) of the huge trucks obstructing traffic and acting as a major safety hazard on West Ave because of the Mondrian hotel.

  4. The city ordinanace declaring roads in Venetian as Highways is part of a RACKETERING scheme to subsidize and favor the towing industry in the beach. I believe that a lawsuit should be brought against the vity for running a racket under color of law.

  5. I agree with the Mondrian Hotel Problem of Trucks like SYSCO, and meat delivery trucks just parked on West Avenue with thier flashers on. It causes us to drive around and makes it dangerous for pedestrians crossing in front of the trucks we cant see. I agree favoratisim is given to Hotels…

  6. I do not understand the parking violation. So no cars are allowed to park on the street on any of the Venetian Islands? Is there a sign posted saying this?

    DO NOT let the Tow company charge you any of these illegal fees1) after hours fee (this fee is not allowed per the towing contract); 2) the labor fee is only allowed if it takes longer than 30 minutues to hook up your car, 3) the administration fee is only allowed if they put a lien against your car.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s